Freedom in the “cloud”?

It’s come to the point that I was asked to explain what I consider necessary prerequisites for an open, free, sustainable approach towards what is often called “The Cloud” or also “Software as a Service” (SaaS).

To be honest, it took some time for me to make up my mind on the matter, and I considered many of the inputs that I’ve seen so far, in particular the Franklin Street Statement on Freedom and Network Services to be good enough for some time.

Clearly I’m sympathetic to the fundamental ideas behind Diaspora, ownCloud and so on. In fact, I myself am currently dedicating my life to the creation of a solution that should empower users to take control over some of their most central data – email, calendar, address books, tasks, see “The Kolab Story” – and thus to provide one puzzle piece to this picture.

So yes, I have developed an opinion by now and obviously I see attempts at “openwashing” such as “Open Surface” by Microsoft to be falling dramatically short on several accounts.

So what do I think constitutes a socially acceptable and sustainable approach to “Cloud Computing” or “SaaS”?

I think it may be simpler than what I initially thought. There are two primary points that now seem most relevant to me:

Right to restrict

Users must be able to restrict access to their own data, especially by their service provider. Participating in social networks, or enjoying the convenience of having your data available at all times should never have to come at the price of giving up privacy. So users must be given a choice to restrict access to their data as much as they consider necessary or desirable, from fellow users, and their provider. Similarly, they should never lose the right in their data simply because they use a certain service.

Freedom to leave, but not lose

Users must be able to switch between providers, or even to host their own data, if they so choose. And they must be able to do so without losing their network.

They should still enjoy the same level of interconnectivity and not be penalized for having switched providers in the form of having to convince all their contacts and friends to switch, as well.

Software such as StatusNet which is powering Identi.ca allows to set up your own instance – this is a step in the right direction.

From these follow a couple of necessary conclusions to get to this point:

Free Software necessary, but not sufficient

Free Software is a necessary, but not a sufficient condition. Without the software being Free Software, the Freedom to leave, but not lose is exceedingly hard to implement. So in my view the GNU Affero General Public License (AGPL) is strongly preferred, followed by the GNU General Public License (GPL) Version 3, but ultimately any Free Software license will do. Implicitly therefore I am also not adverse to allowing companies to differentiate themselves to some level on code, as long as that does not violate the principles above.

Decentralized & Federated

In order to allow switching without losing the network, any software in this context should be designed federated and decentralized, based on protocols that allow such interconnectivity as well as re-discovering users that have moved.

Open Standards

In order to facilitate the connection of services and providers, as well as allow for innovation and differentiation, a certain level of freedom to experiment is necessary. So software and services should provide truly Open Standards with ongoing interoperability work through plug-fests and automated test suites which give some indication on how well which services actually interoperate.

Transparent Privacy Policies

In order to have control over data, users first need to understand what they are (or are not) allowing the provider to do, which is typically not the case. Most users have never read the 20 page privacy statements which are written in ways that make telephone books seem an entertaining read. So we need a way to simplify this.

A set of standardized privacy policies, maybe with a simple visualization approach similar to what Creative Commons came up with, would be a very useful step forward here.

No change of policy without explicit consent

And naturally it should be illegal to change privacy policies on users without their explicit consent. They need to know what is changing, and how, and what will be the resulting level of privacy they enjoy – in the same clear, transparent and understandable manner.

Because much of this is fuzzy in the sense of being open to interpretation and evaluation, these will require monitoring, either through existing consumer protection bodies, through antitrust or standardisation groups, an existing or new NGO dedicated to this work, or something else. Off the top of my head I cannot think of a body that has both the mandate and competency to fulfil such a task.

So while I have some ideas, I obviously still don’t have all the answers.

Be Sociable, Share!

About Georg Greve

Georg Greve is a technologist and entrepreneur. Background as a software developer and physicist. Head of product development and Chairman at Vereign AG. Founding president of the Free Software Foundation Europe (FSFE). Previously president and CEO at Kolab Systems AG, a Swiss Open Source ISV. In 2009 Georg was awarded the Federal Cross of Merit on Ribbon by the Federal Republic of Germany for his contributions to Open Source and Open Standards.
This entry was posted in Collaborate in Confidence, Fellowship, Free Software Business, Free Software Foundation Europe, Open Standards, Political Commentary. Bookmark the permalink.

183 Responses to Freedom in the “cloud”?

  1. Hello friends I am madam Maya escorts service provider in patna. Our call girls in Patna have wide range of call girls for you. You may chose as per your wish and enjoy there beauty. you will never feel like stranger or wired with these baby , madam maya is always available for your entertainment.

  2. Hello guys! I am Sneha Independent escorts in Jammu. a innocent charm combined with a knowing mind and a naughty imagination. I am here to offer you good moment of Jammu Escorts Service , I will not dissapoint your expectation.I am open for all your fantasy , let’s meet and you will never forget me !

  3. Hi I am Dia Roy Independent Ludhiana Escorts in Ludhiana .Passionate hearts of males are always found to be filled with insurmountable passions and fantasies and such lively desires and the wish for charming girls and pretty ladies is always the most innate one among such thoughts

  4. bedava bahis says:

    bir çok bahis sitesinin vermiş olduğu bedava bonuslar sayesinde yeni müşteriler çekmektedir.

  5. Hello friends I am madam Maya escorts service provider in patna. Our call girls in Patna have wide range of call girls for you.

  6. sara says:

    escorts in islamabad

  7. We ensure our exclusive, high-end Islamabad Escorts are the most beautiful available, and are refined off with delightful personalities. We are punctual, thus providing superior global courtesan dating services. Look through our booking options for your Islamabad trip to ensure the highest quality service. Our luxury, high-end Islamabad Escorts range in age from 21 years old and up. All are highly educated and very elegant. We are the best VIP, elite escort group serving Islamabad. No matter where you are coming from, we are well worth the trip.

  8. We ensure our exclusive, high-end Islamabad Escorts are the most beautiful available, and are refined off with delightful personalities. We are punctual, thus providing superior global courtesan dating services. Look through our booking options for your Islamabad trip to ensure the highest quality service. Our luxury, high-end Islamabad Escorts range in age from 21 years old and up. All are highly educated and very elegant. We are the best VIP, elite escort group serving Islamabad. No matter where you are coming from, we are well worth the trip. http://www.vipescortislamabad.com Thats our best destination for services

  9. We ensure our exclusive, high-end Islamabad Escorts are the most beautiful available, and are refined off with delightful personalities. We are punctual, thus providing superior global courtesan dating services. Look through our booking options for your Islamabad trip to ensure the highest quality service. http://www.vipescortislamabad.com Our luxury, high-end Islamabad Escorts range in age from 21 years old and up. All are highly educated and very elegant. We are the best VIP, elite escort group serving Islamabad. No matter where you are coming from, we are well worth the trip.

  10. Please visit the website for independent Escorts Services in Pakistan and escorts in Pakistan. Our services are available 24*7.

  11. your article so awesome..

  12. Thanks to my father who informed me about this weblog, this web site is actually remarkable.

  13. Are you facing the trouble to find Kolkata escorts services? Then, you need to contact with Rituparna Das an independent kolkata call girls for your erotic session.

  14. Megha Patil says:

    Thank for sharing post.

  15. Thanks for help full information.

  16. We are offering female Independent Escorts in Lahore and escorts service Lahore. Visit our website for more information.

  17. vanshika says:

    Hi I am Vaanshika having Ludhiana Escorts in Ludhiana .Passionate hearts of males are always found to be filled with insurmountable passions and fantasies and such lively desires and the wish for charming girls and pretty ladies is always the most innate one among such thoughts for men.

  18. I Am Ritu Sharma. I Am An Independent Mumbai Escort Girl. I Deal In Mumbai Escorts Service

  19. For Best Airtel Customer Support Please Visit here.

  20. Honey says:

    Vodafone Customer Care Number, All State Vodafone Customer Care Number and vodafone toll Free Number.

  21. Aayah Khan says:

    Thanks for your great post, I had been Looking for this information a long time, here you share the messages, I’m very happy to see the perfect article. Awesome!

  22. Aziza Diwan says:

    Your content has a professional approach. I Am going to see more and learn more from your upcoming write-ups.

  23. Sofia Khan says:

    The tested and proven content You Have Mentioned is really exclusive. I like checking out the details that you put on your content.

  24. Wonderful story and please write more Items on Your site and I want to read more about this story. Thank you for story.

  25. sayna Nandy says:

    It’s almost impossible to find experienced Individuals for this particular subject, however, you sound like you know what you are talking about!

  26. I am a Priya Jain, I have a lot of support for you, but I have a lot of research on the site’s blog, I hope that I will also like to thank you for this.
    Call Girls In Gurgaon

  27. thanks for the article

  28. We Are Best Islamabad Escorts Agency in Islamabad Call +923098998125. We Have Vip, Top, Model, Elite, Student, College, School Escorts in Islamabad. http://escortsinislamabad.com/

  29. arpitajain says:

    I Am Thankful To You For Create Such Kind Of Informative Website. Really It Is Useful According Your Current Topic. I Suggest To Keep This Continue For Those People, Who Are Looking For Such Kind Of Niche. After See Your Niche I Have Recommended Your Website With My Friends Also.
    I amArpita Jain. I run my own Mumbai Escort Service. We provide Mumbai call Girls in low cost according the current market price. Our service is super, because we know very well the personal requirement of our each customer. We are comfortable to provide ourMumbai Call Girls Service at your home or in Hotel. Visit- http://www.arpitajain.org/mumbai-call-girls/
    Call- +91 9OO4458359
    Visit The Links Below And Have A Look At My Various Escort Services-
    Mumbai Escorts
    Mumbai Call Girls
    Escort Service In Mumbai
    Mumbai Escort Girls
    Bandra Escorts
    Juhu Escorts
    Andheri Escorts

  30. Abrana Desai says:

    I’ve a numerous more lovely girls associated with me who a number of them might be linked with any agency, but here they have more independent of working hours plus they do not have to inject their earnings for anyone.

  31. Abrana Desai says:

    I am happy to see this website..

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

*

You may use these HTML tags and attributes: <a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <cite> <code> <del datetime=""> <em> <i> <q cite=""> <strike> <strong>

Spam Protection by WP-SpamFree