The Post-PRISM Society: Totalitarian Clouds

After a somewhat brief overview over the world we find ourselves in, the question is what does this mean to us as a society?

As highlighted in the previous article, governments have no realistic option not to engage in some form of activities to protect their people from threats that originate on-line or have an on-line component. These were the grounds for German chancellor Angela Merkel to make statements of support for PRISM. The problem is that I doubt it is effective and adequate to the threat. The side effects seem out of sync with the gain. That this gain is only claimed, not proven due to alleged security concerns, also does nothing to help the case.

It has become public knowledge these technologies exist and make mass surveillance can and is being implemented, and works efficiently. Calling for a general ban is unrealistic, and naive. Of course these technologies will be used against people, businesses and governments by someone – be they states or organisations. So the actual question is: Which are the circumstances under which use of such technology is acceptable?

Looking at the initial reactions, a great number of people – consciously or not – base their reaction on Article 12 of the Universal Declaration of Human Rights. And considering the consequences, that does not seem very far fetched.

Consequences of the Surveillance Society

There are some stories floating around where people have suffered repercussions such as being denied entry to the United States. But that’s probably the extent of it for many of us unless you are a public figure, or ever find yourself in a job where you would have influence on a decision that might be of major consequence to the United States.

But that’s only the fairly superficial perspective.

Consider for a moment the Arab spring where governments desperately tried to remain in power. In several cases the governments overthrown were the same ones that received strategic and practical support by the United States – including military and secret service activities – as part of their plans for the region. These governments in their desperate attempts to retain control knew which activists to imprison, sometimes torture and often confronted them with their own private messages from Facebook and Twitter.

Could those governments have to obtained that data itself? Possibly. But there is another option.

FISA makes it legal for the United States to obtain and make use of that data for the strategic interests of the United States. And Prism would have made it almost trivial. So the simpler way for those governments to know what was planned would have been to receive dossiers from their US contacts. Does this prove it happened that way? Certainly not. But it demonstrates the level of influence this combination of technical ability is giving the United States and other countries.

“Still,” most people think ‘I am living in a safe country and have no plans to overthrow my government.’

Nothing to hide, nothing to fear” has been used to justify surveillance for a long time. It’s a simple and wrong answer. Because everyone has areas they would prefer to remain private. If someone has the ability to threaten you with exposing something you do not wish to see exposed, they have power over you. But what’s more: People who have to assume to be watched at all times, even in their most intimate moments and inner thoughts, behave differently.

A culture of surveillance leads to self regulation, with fundamental impact how people behave at all times. Will you still speak up against things you perceive as wrong when you fear there might be repercussions? Or would you perhaps ask yourself whether this particular issue is important enough to risk so much, and hope that it won’t be as bad, or that someone else will take action?

Also, consider the situation of people who absolutely rely upon a certain level of privacy for their professional lives, such as lawyers, journalists and others. That no-one in these professions should be using these services should be self-evident. But if a society adopts the “Nothing to hide, nothing to fear” dogma, those who communicate for good reason with such professions will stand out as dark shadows in an otherwise fully lit room, and will raise suspicion.

If privacy becomes the exception those who require privacy will easily be singled out. The only way to avoid this is to make privacy the norm: If everyone has privacy, no-one will be suspicious for it.

And there are good reasons you would want to do your part to live in such a society, because the functioning of democracy as a whole is linked to a set of factors, including a working media, ability to form political opinion, and become politically active to achieve change for the better. And even if you yourself have no ambition in this way at this point in time.

Privacy is one of the essential building blocks of a free society.

You might find yourself activated by misspent tax money, a new highway being planned through your back yard, or the plans to re-purpose your favourite city park for a shopping mall. And if it isn’t yourself, perhaps something will make your parents, siblings, spouse, kids, best friend want to take action and then require a society that grants privacy in order not to be intimidated into silence.

So there are good reasons why people worry about this level of surveillance.

Why, then, are they choosing to voluntarily support it?

Feudal Agents of the Totalitarian State

It has been subject of discussion in the software freedom community for some time, but only now appears to hit the radar of a larger subset of the forward thinking IT literates: The large US service providers own users and their data in ways that led security guru Bruce Schneier to comparing them to feudal lords, leaving their users as hapless peasants in a global Game of Thrones power struggle.

Some time ago already, Geek & Poke probably summarized it slightly more pointedly:

Geek & Poke:

One aspect of using these services is that users place themselves under surveillance as part of their payment for the service. The plethora of knowledge Facebook keeps on everyone that is using it, and everyone that is not using it, has been disclosed time and again, last time during the shadow profile exposure. But this has not been the first time. Nor can anyone reasonably expect Google, Microsoft or Apple to behave any different.

What is important to understand is that the centralisation of these services, and turning devices into increasingly dumb data gathering and supply devices is not accidental, nor is it technologically necessary. We all carry around a lot more computing power all the time than was readily available just some years ago.

So these devices and services could operate in a de-centralized and meshed fashion.

But then the companies would not get to profile their users in such detail, potentially gathering every intimate detail about them, such as whether they were aroused when they last used voice search to find the nearest hotel. Or did you think that command was analysed on your smart phone, and not by the (almost) infinitely powerful processing power in the data centres of your service provider?

Data is the new gold, and these companies are mining it as best they can.

Naturally these companies are always downplaying the amount of data collected, or the impact that use of this data might have on individuals. PRISM exposed this carefully crafted fallacy to some extent.

It also raised the question: What is it worse? That the government which can be held accountable to a larger degree gets access to some data gathered by a company? Or that a company that is responsible to no-one but its shareholders gathered all of it?

In fact, cynically speaking, one might even think these companies are mostly unhappy about the fact that the US government wants free, unlimited access to the raw data rather than the paid for refined access they offer as part of their business model.

But the root cause is in the centralised gathering of such data under terms that do not make these companies your service providers, but you their peasant. This treasure trove will always attract desires, and countries have ways to get access because they have ways to impact profits. Now that the PRISM disclosure taught them what’s possible, countries such as Turkey are quickly catching on, demanding access to details of Gezi protesters.

So while these companies are often wrapping themselves in liberty, the internet and all that is good for humankind, by their existence and business model they make a contribution to a totalitarian society.

Whether that contribution is decisive, or outweighs the instances where they do good, I cannot judge.

But using these providers for your services and getting all up in arms about PRISM is somewhat hypocritical, I’m afraid. It’s a bit like complaining about losing your foot when you’ve voluntarily and without need amputated your entire leg before to be able to make use of the special “one-legged all you can eat buffet.”

Choices for Free Citizens

So assuming you want to break free of this surveillance and the tendencies towards a totalitarian society, which are your options?

Firstly, choose Open Source / Free Software and Open Standards. There is a plethora of applications out there and the way in which their internal workings and control structures are transparent and publicly developed makes it much more likely they will not provide back doors to your data. Following the PRISM leaks, sites such as http://prism-break.org have sprung up that try to help you do just that.

Secondly, start making use of encryption, which is easier and more effective than you might think.

Chances are that someone in your circle of friends or family is already using some or even many of these applications. Get them to help you get started yourself.

But assuming you are not a technical person, which is most of society, the most important choice you can likely make is with your feet and wallet by choosing services that work for you and put themselves at your service – rather than services that process you and put you at their service.

The important place for this is to look at the terms of the services you are using.

I know this is tedious, and these terms are often deliberately written to make eyes glaze over when trying to understand what they actually say.

But there is a web site that can help you with it: Terms of Service; Didn’t Read. Check out the services you are currently using, and get yourself the browser extension so you at least start getting an idea of what kinds of rights you are surrendering by making use of the services.

As for providers that offer you the same convenience, but without the mandatory cavity search, there are still quite a few. Naturally it makes sense to look at their terms of services carefully, ensure they are based in a legislation of your choice, and use technologies that you can trust. If you are not sure, ask them to explain what standards they observe with regards your data. And ensure you can switch providers, even switch to self-hosting if you want to, without necessarily changing technologies.

And once you’ve looked through all those criteria and made your homework on which solutions can deliver all of this, without compromise, take control of your data and software.

Disclaimer

I’m not a party without interest in this debate. You can easily inform yourself about what I’ve done in the past in this area. And my past years I’ve dedicated to building a technology that would allow people to own their data and software, while providing all the features users have grown accustomed to.

That technology is called Kolab, and of course I’d be delighted if you got in touch with us, or installed Kolab.org on your own, or even made use of the http://MyKolab.com service. Because all of this will help us continue to work to the goal of allowing people secure, powerful collaboration across platforms while owning their own data and software.

But it’s this work that has followed from my analysis, not the other way around.

So make up your own mind.


All articles:

Be Sociable, Share!

About Georg Greve

Georg Greve is a technologist and entrepreneur. Background as a software developer and physicist. Head of product development and Chairman at Vereign AG. Founding president of the Free Software Foundation Europe (FSFE). Previously president and CEO at Kolab Systems AG, a Swiss Open Source ISV. In 2009 Georg was awarded the Federal Cross of Merit on Ribbon by the Federal Republic of Germany for his contributions to Open Source and Open Standards.
This entry was posted in Collaborate in Confidence, Political Commentary and tagged , , , , , , , , . Bookmark the permalink.

22 Responses to The Post-PRISM Society: Totalitarian Clouds

  1. greve says:

    An excellent analysis on the social impact of PRISM by Derek Khanna: If PRISM Is Good Policy, Why Stop With Terrorism?

    The danger of a surveillance state is not the obscure chance of a truly evil person abusing the system; rather, the actual threat, the real danger, is a person with good intentions who believes that their draconian actions are morally justified and prudent. It is such a leader, perhaps with the best of intentions, who can make the most heinous of mistakes with eyes wide open and belief that the ends justify the means. Those ends never justify eviscerating the Fourth Amendment.”

    And naturally, the same is true in other countries.

    Today’s example being provided by the Muslim brotherhood in Egypt, which I am sure was perfectly well-meaning in their own moral context. It’s just that virtue applied with broad strokes and force-fed to everyone is truly a terror to behold.

  2. Pingback: Life post-PRISM: No More Business Secrets « freedom bits

  3. Pingback: Groklaw shutting down. « freedom bits

  4. Aniva smith says:

    Free citizenship is fine but what will be about safety monitor
    ? Is it safe and what precautions government taken yet?
    Thanks in advance

  5. iasbaba says:

    Today’s example being provided by the Muslim brotherhood in Egypt, which I am sure was perfectly well-meaning in their own moral context. It’s just that virtue applied with broad strokes and force-fed to everyone is truly a terror to behold.

  6. Digihunt says:

    The danger of a surveillance state is not the obscure chance of a truly evil person abusing the system; rather, the actual threat, the real danger, is a person with good intentions who believes that their draconian actions are morally justified

  7. The danger of a surveillance state is not the obscure chance of a truly evil person abusing the system.

  8. Here’s how you can livestream the Canelo vs Jacobs fight. Learn where you can watch it, what it’ll cost and on what devices you can check it out.

  9. nba finals mvp says:

    ESPN: You can find a nba finals mvp live stream via ESPN’s WatchESPN app or on the ESPN website. Unfortunately, you’ll need to authenticate with a cable provider if you want to utilize this NBA playoffs live stream option, so get your (or your friend’s/parent’s!) login credentials ready. You can download the free WatchESPN app for your iOS, Android, or Amazon device.

  10. Canelo Alvarez Live Stream reddit says:

    Canelo vs Jacobs Fight Live Stream Free Online . He was once the middleweight champion and he dropped that after Golovkin beat him. They understood the difficult need to change a stale product for younger audiences in 2019.

    Get Canelo Alvarez vs Daniel Jacobs Fight Date, Time, Live Stream Coverage, Odds and Boxing Preview.

  11. Observe safety precautions when playing motion games. With the surging popularity of motion-based games, there has also been an increase in incidents of property damage and injury related to them. Make sure you have plenty of room, and don’t stand too close to other players to avoid hitting them. If necessary, move furniture to create more playing space.
    How To Win Free PayPal Cash in 2019 – Unlimited Free Money

  12. Thanks for the informative and helpful post, obviously in your blog everything is good.I am Sharing That Deontay Wilder vs Dominic Breazeale Fight will be take place on May 18 2019 ..Watch Deontay Wilder vs Dominic Breazeale from anywhere in the world . Watch Wilder Live Stream .

  13. new south wales vs Queensland Rugby Live
    NEW South Wales has delivered a hammer blow to Queensland at the MCG to take a 1-0 lead in the 2018 State of Origin series.

    The Blues scored three unanswered tries to fightback from 12-8 down mid-way through the second half to blow the Maroons off the turf.

    Tries to Lattrell Mitchell, Tom Trbojevic and Josh Addo-Carr saw NSW charge to a 22-12 win that has given the Blues a chance to win the series when they return to Sydney for Game 2 at ANZ Stadium on Sunday, June 24.

    James Tedesco was named man of the match after producing a freakish 16 tackle breaks and 224m carrying the Steededn while Blues hooker Damien Cook and inspirational Queensland captain Greg Inglis were also mighty for their respective teams.

  14. A very well designed and slick blog that’s all about being your own boss and creating your own wealth. It’s a blog with a very active podcast feed. Their podcasts are insanely popular on itunes, and no doubt they make a fair bit of money from selling ad space on those podcasts. Podcasts is something to think about when creating your blog as it could be a great monetization tool.
    Watch Spider Man Far From Home Full Movie

  15. Thank you for the auspicious writeup. It in truth was a enjoyment account it.
    Look advanced to far added agreeable from you! By the way, how could we keep up a correspondence?

  16. Thank you for the auspicious writeup. It in truth was a enjoyment account it.
    Look advanced to far added agreeable from you! By the way, how could we keep up a correspondence? X Men Dark Phoenix Full Movie Online

  17. This is a fantastic blog to me that’s why I want to give a lot of thanks to admin and request to admin for this site continue handaling.Gennady Golovkin will Come Back for the ring after His First Very First Decrease If he Matches Canada’s Steve Rolls on June 8 in New York’s Madison Square Garden.The purpose is usually to be streamed on DAZN.

  18. Watch the 2019 Tony Awards live online at CBS.com. Watch performances, clips, follow us backstage and join the after party.

    The 73rd Annual Tony Awards will be held on June 9, 2019, to recognize achievement in Broadway productions during the 2018–19 season. The ceremony will be held at Radio City Music Hall in New York City and will be broadcast live by CBS. James Corden will serve as host.

    Event date:: June 10, 2019, 00:00 AM GMT

  19. Thank you for the insightful and useful informative article, obviously on your site everything is good.I’m Sharing That Watch US Open Championship .The tradition continues this year, when Pebble Beach hosts its sixth U.S. Open on June 10-16, 2019!. Watch US Open Golf Live Free US Open Live Stream US Open Golf Results us open golf live scoring US Open Golf live results US Open Golf Coverage.

  20. Thank you for the insightful and useful informative article, obviously on your site everything is good.I’m Sharing That Watch US Open Championship .The tradition continues this year, when Pebble Beach hosts its sixth U.S. Open on June 10-16, 2019!. Watch US Open Golf Live Free US Open Live Stream US Open Golf Results us open golf live scoring US Open Golf live results US Open Golf Coverage.

  21. Thank you for the insightful and useful informative article, obviously on your site everything is good.I’m Sharing That Watch US Open Championship .The tradition continues this year, when Pebble Beach hosts its sixth U.S. Open on June 10-16, 2019!. Watch US Open Golf Live Free US Open Live Stream US Open Golf Results us open golf live scoring US Open Golf live results US Open Golf Coverage.

  22. Nick Jones says:

    My name is Alyssa Nikkel, from Toronto, Ontario.

    I’m a second-year forensic science student from Ontario Tech University. Last year I have had the chance to attend coaching and choice teams for Team Canada in the upcoming World University Games (FISU). I am so pleased to say this past week in our training camp at Oshawa, I got the information I have been chosen and will soon be travelling into Napoli Italy that summer to play with Canada!

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

*

You may use these HTML tags and attributes: <a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <cite> <code> <del datetime=""> <em> <i> <q cite=""> <strike> <strong>

Spam Protection by WP-SpamFree