What makes a Free Software company?

(The debates on the European Software Strategy came across several issues that are of general interest, but the debates themselves cannot be disclosed for reasons of procedural confidentiality. Instead, this article takes one issue and discusses it from a personal perspective.)

Although it seems somewhat antiquated today, “How do you make money with Free Software?” was a very common question just a few years ago. Today, that question has evolved into “What are successful business strategies that can be implemented on top of Free Software?”

This question is a lot more focussed already, and came up several times during the discussions around the European Software Strategy, with pointers to noteworthy contributions from various people, such as Matthew Aslett, Carlo Daffara or Matt Asay. Another person who recently took a shot at answering this question is Anoop John, who I met in Kerala two years ago.

After several years in the field, helping entrepreneurs find business models that work for them, discussing the question of Free Software companies, and the diversity of a community that is both commercial and non-commercial at the same time, a few things occurred to me that I wanted to share.

Point 1: Think clearly

In order to develop business strategies, it is first necessary to have a clear understanding of the different aspects that you seek to address. Unfortunately this is not made easier by popular ambiguous use of some terms for fundamentally different concepts and issues, e.g. “Open Source” being used for a software model, development model, or business model.

These models are orthogonal, like the three axes of the three-dimensional coordinate system, their respective differentiators are control (software model), collaboration (development model), revenue (business model).

The software model axis is the one that is discussed most often. On the one hand there is proprietary software, for which the vendor retains full control over the software and the user receives limited usage permission through a license, which is granted according to certain conditions. On the other hand there is Free Software, which provides the user with unprecedented control over their software through an ex-ante grant of irrevocable and universal rights to use, study, modify and distribute the software.

The development model axis describes the barrier to collaboration, ranging from projects that are developed by a single person or vendor to projects that allow extensive global collaboration. This is independent from the software model. There is proprietary software that allows for far-reaching collaboration, e.g. SAP with it’s partnership program, and Free Software projects that are developed by a single person or company with little or no outside input.

The business model axis describes what kind of revenue model was chosen for the software. Options on this axis include training, services, integration, custom development, subscription models, “Commercial Off The Shelve” (COTS), “Software as a Service” (SaaS) and more.

These three axes open the space in which any software project and any product of any company can freely position itself. That is not to say all these combinations will be successful. A revenue model based on lock-in strategies with rapid paid upgrade cycles is unlikely to work with Free Software as the underlying software model. This approach typically occurs on top of a proprietary software model for which the business model mandates a completed financial transaction as one of the conditions to grant a license.

It should be noted that the overlap of possible business models on top of the different software models is much larger than usually understood. The ex-ante grant of the Free Software model makes it generally impossible to attach conditions to the granting of a license, including the condition of financial transaction. But it is possible to implement very similar revenue streams in the business model through contractual constructions, trademarks and/or certification.

Each of these axes warrants individual consideration and careful planning for the goals of the project.

If, for instance the goal is to work with competitors on a non-differentiating component in order to achieve independence from a potential monopolistic supplier, it would seem appropriate to focus on collaboration and choose a software model that includes a strong Copyleft licence. The business model could potentially be neglected in this case, as the expected return on investment comes in the form of strategic independence benefits, and lower licence costs.

In another case, a company might choose a very collaborative community development model on top of a strong Copyleft licence, with a revenue model based on enterprise-ready releases that are audited for maturity, stability and security by the company for its customers.

The number of possible combinations is almost endless, and the choices made will determine the individual character and competitive strengths and weaknesses of each company. Thinking clearly about these parameters is key to a successful business strategy.

Point 2: Freedom moving up the stack

According to Gartner, usage of Free Software will reach 100 percent by November 2009. That makes usage of Free Software a poor criterion for what makes a Free Software company. Contribution to Free Software projects seems a slightly better choice, but as many Free Software projects have adopted a collaborative development model in which the users themselves drive development, that label would then also apply to companies that aren’t Information Technology (IT) companies.

IT companies are among the most intensive users of software, and will often find themselves as part of a larger stack or environment of applications. Being part of that stack, their use of software not only refers to desktops and servers used by the company’s employees, but also to the platform on top of which the company’s software or solution is provided.

Maintaining proprietary custom platforms for a solution is inefficient and expensive, and depending upon other proprietary companies for the platform is dangerous. In response, large proprietary enterprises have begun to phase out their proprietary platforms and are moving towards Free Software in order to leverage the strategic advantages provided by this software model for their own use of software on the platform level. These companies will often interact well with the projects they depend upon, contribute to them, and foster their growth as a way to develop strategic independence as a user of software.

What makes these enterprises proprietary is that for the parts where they are not primarily users of software, but suppliers to their downstream customers, the software model is proprietary, withholding from its customers the same strategic benefits of Free Software that the company is using to improve its own competitiveness.

From a customer perspective, that solution itself becomes part of the platform on which the company’s differentiating activities are based. This, as stated before, is inefficient, expensive and a dangerous strategy.

Assuming a market perspective, it represents an inefficiency that provides business opportunity for other companies to provide customers with a stack that is Free Software entirely, and it is strategically and economically sane for customers to prefer those providers over proprietary ones for the very same reasons that their proprietary suppliers have chosen Free Software platforms themselves.

Strategically speaking, any company that includes proprietary software model components in its revenue model should be aware that its revenue flow largely depends upon lack of Free Software alternatives, and that growth of the market, as well as supernatural profits generated through the proprietary model both serve to attract other companies that will make proprietary models unsustainable. When that moment comes, the company can either move its revenue model to a different market, or it has to transform its revenue source to work on top of a software model that is entirely Free Software.

So usage of and contribution to Free Software are not differentiators for what makes a Free Software company. The critical differentiator is provision of Free Software downstream to customers. In other words: Free Software companies are companies that have adopted business models in which the revenue streams are not tied to proprietary software model licensing conditions.

Up next

But every company naturally needs a differentiator that provides its unique sales proposition, the one thing that it can do better, cheaper, faster than anyone else and that provides the reason for customers to choose that particular company over another.

Traditionally, many IT companies have relied upon proprietary software models and patents for uniqueness and differentiation. This is particularly apparent in the venture capital environment, and lack of these sources of uniqueness is often perceived as a strategic weakness.

So in one of my next articles I am planning to show how differentiators used by Free Software companies can be as strong as those of proprietary companies, and that the differentiators of proprietary companies are often much less unique than it appears.

Be Sociable, Share!

About Georg Greve

Georg Greve is CEO and President of the Board at Kolab Systems AG, a Swiss Open Source ISV for collaboration and communication, also available as Swiss hosted service Kolab Now. During his 20+ year career in Free and Open Source Software he has been author of the Brave GNU World, one of the most widely spread columns on the subject, founding president of the Free Software Foundation Europe (FSFE) and provided input to various governmental and inter-governmental organisations. In 2009 Georg was awarded the Federal Cross of Merit on Ribbon by the Federal Republic of Germany for his contributions to Open Source and Open Standards.
This entry was posted in Free Software Business and tagged , . Bookmark the permalink.

86 Responses to What makes a Free Software company?

  1. David Marsh says:

    Nepal is adventure and romantic places of the new couples. There are a lots of places to start the marry life enjoy. Did you marryed in recently, you need the romantic places, peaceful lakes. You choose the better location of the Nepal. Enjoy the marry life for the couples, Nepal Honeymoon Packages.
    Visit us: https://www.travels2nepal.com/nepal-honeymoon-package

  2. Thank You So Much For providing the important information.

  3. Amazing article thanks or sharing..

  4. Making money from free software is much easier than as compared to the purchased one.

  5. Really i appreciate the effort you made to share the knowledge. This is really a great stuff for sharing. Keep it up . Thanks for sharing.

  6. CDR Report says:

    I found this is an informative and interesting blog so I think so it is very useful and knowledgeable. I would like to thank you for the efforts you have made in writing this blog. We also provide blog CDR Report Australia.

  7. Develop your marketing skills Mobile Repairing. ABC Mobile Institute of Technology is successfully training students since a long time. Join the best Mobile Training Institute in Delhi. We provide 3 months training in Mobile Repairing Course. We are the best provider of the course in just 20000/- Rs. Contact us at 9990879879

  8. Great! Your post is amazing and interesting. Thanks for share!
    These interesting games help you relax after a long day of fatigue.

  9. Thank you so much so helpful

  10. Betmatik says:

    Betmatik bahis şirketinin ilk ve tek destek platformu. Thank you so much

  11. Hello
    My name is Sarah Smith and This is a very nice post. Thanks for sharing with us. Keep it up.

  12. Assignment Help says:

    An unmatched and nonpareil post i have ever seen. The content is so appealing that it has created an impulse to avail Singapore services.

  13. An unmatched and nonpareil post i have ever seen. The content is so appealing that it has created an impulse to avail Singapore services.

  14. An unmatched and nonpareil post i have ever seen. The content is so appealing that it has created an impulse to avail Singapore services.

  15. Hello

    Cheap Assignment help provide best Assignment Help University and School students at affordable prices with 100% satisfaction on different educational topic like Marketing, Business, Human Resource Management, Health and Social Care etc.

    cheap assignment help

  16. By Visiting This Site I Found Cool Stuff Here Keep It Up.

  17. Good Way Of Telling, Good Post To Take Facts Regarding My Presentation Subject Matter, Which I Am Going To Deliver In My College

  18. CDR Report says:

    The blog you have shared is very good. This is really interesting information for me. Thanks for sharing! We also provide CDR Report.

  19. james lara says:

    Thank you for your kind comments. Of course you can share this on your blog. Please let me know when it has be published.

    Game Lover – https://games.lol/arcade/

  20. Puzzle Games says:

    Wonderful post Thanks for sharing this kind of wonderful article..Very nice information.

  21. Puzzle Games says:

    Great to see your site up. This is a wonderful piece and I’ll be sharing!

  22. Great work did by you. Informative and problem-solving content that users can easily digest can work for all types of blogs. When a user finds something informative on a blog, he/she is more likely to come back from your side.

  23. Thank you so much mobilbahis giriş adresleri ve daha fazlası.

  24. I Loved The Way You Discuss The Topic Great Work Thanks For The Share.

  25. Amazing Article Thanks Or Sharing..

  26. You should have clearly define topics which you want to learn and start collecting study material according to that topics. Also some assignment help service you can use to get knowledge as well. Just proceed accordingly and don’t waste your time because time is precious.

  27. Excellent and nice post. It will beneficial for everyone. Thanks for sharing such a wonderful post. Avail No 1 Dissertation Help UK from certified PhD writers. It is extremely helpful for me. You can email us at info@ukdissertationhelp.co.uk or Phone Number – 020 8144 9988

  28. My name is Michael Smith and This is a very nice post. Thanks for sharing with us. Keep it up.

  29. I am always searching online for articles that can help me. There is obviously a lot to know about this. I think you made some good points in Features also. Keep working, great job !

    Custom Assignment Help

  30. erica says:

    Great and amazing. The blog is important to express what you think. Les espadons de ma jeunesse n’étaient pas tous des thons.

  31. TruckGuru LLP is a cheap Packers and Movers service provider operating in India, serving over 10 years.

  32. roxysmith says:

    this is roxy smith.
    great and really amazing.
    Get the best perdisco assignment help in Australia.

  33. We work with the team of masters and Ph.D. experts with amazing knowledge in the field of your study and make sure you score and higher grades ever. Are you demanding for My Assignment Help services from professional experts? U don’t know and come at StudentsAssignmentHelp.com

  34. Youwin bonus kampanyaları, yeni giriş adresleri ve daha fazlası sitemizde sizlerle.

  35. Get best online assignment help from Professionals and submit a perfect work on time.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *


You may use these HTML tags and attributes: <a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <cite> <code> <del datetime=""> <em> <i> <q cite=""> <strike> <strong>

Spam Protection by WP-SpamFree