Weblog

Author of ATSC Capture and Edit Tool tries to revoke GPL

As seen on slashdot, the author of the ATSC Capture and edit tool has placed a notice of license revokal at sourceforge.net. While the GPLv2-FAQ states that a program licensed under the GPL cannot be re-licenced to someone else exclusively, both the FAQ and the license text itself don’t actually say anything about the license not being irrevokable. While one could interpret the absence of an arbitrary revokation clause (GPv2L can terminate automatically in case of violation) as a hint the license cannot be revoked indeed, a nifty lawyer could well come up with a convincing-sounding argument for the opposite.

Perhaps someone with a proper legal background (FSFE-TF, SFLC anyone?) could contact the author and try to convince him to withdraw that statement. It’s already making its way around the internet, just google for artscap and you’ll come up with a few hits. This might give people the wrong idea and lead more developers to try to revoke licenses for GPL’ed projects.

2 Responses to “Author of ATSC Capture and Edit Tool tries to revoke GPL”

  1. shane Says:

    Groklaw article on the issue

    “One can’t retroactively revoke licenses previously granted, unless the license terms allow you to do so.
    The most you can do is stop granting new licenses.”
    http://www.groklaw.net/article.php?story=2006062204552163

  2. Michael Kallas Says:

    GNU GPL FAQ

    The entry you cite says it quite clearly:
    …the public already has the right to use the program under the GPL, and this right cannot be withdrawn.

Leave a Reply

You must be logged in to post a comment.